Showing posts with label Marx. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Marx. Show all posts

Thursday, October 16, 2014

False Conscious (Marxism) and The Hunger Games


An important concept that Marx introduces to explain the failure of the proletariat to recognize their position as a unified class and their need to band together in order to overthrow capitalism.  One way to think about false consciousness is the sense of hope that individual people have that they might rise to a position within the ranks of the Bourgeoisie.

This scene from the Movie "The Hunger Games" is analogous to the concept of false consciousness.  In this scene President Snow explains why The Hunger Games has a victor, rather than having all participants die, or simply rounding up the sacrifices and executing them.

President Snow: Seneca... why do you think we have a winner?
Seneca Crane: [frowns] What do you mean?
President Snow: I mean, why do we have a winner? I mean, if we just wanted to intimidate the districts, why not round up twenty-four of them at random and execute them all at once? Be a lot faster.
[Seneca just stares, confused]
President Snow: Hope.
Seneca Crane: Hope?
President Snow: Hope. It is the only thing stronger than fear. A little hope is effective. A lot of hope is dangerous. A spark is fine, as long as it's contained.
Seneca Crane: So...?
President Snow: So, CONTAIN it.

As has been noted by numerous literary and internet commentators The Hunger Games is more than a dystopian thriller, it also contains commentary and critique about our current political and economic systems.  In the fictional world of the Hunger Games an oppressive government of a fictional country named Panem has lead to vast wealth inequality: both in terms of intradistrict wealth and in comparing the capital city to the districts.   In part this wealth disparity has resulted from a failed rebellion, though it seems the disparity may also have been the initial cause of the rebellion.  In this fictional account, the capital city is filled with wealthy elites (Bourgeoisie) who own the means of production and live in a state of decadence and ease.  The proletariat are separated into 12 districts and their lives are filled with suffering and work. The separation into districts can be interpreted as an attempt to prevent further rebellion by making class identification more difficult for these workers.  The Hunger Games are an annual event where two youths (1 boy and 1 girl) are chosen from each district to compete in a battle to the death - until only one competitor remains.  In additional to providing the hope that President Snow mentions in the above clip, these games foster resentment and competition between the districts and reinforce the cultural structure within Panem that the districts deserve to be punished for their crime of rebellion.  This is particularly true as districts 1 & 2 have more resources than the other 10, allowing them to train tributes and more often win the games than other districts - this can be thought of as analogous to the Petite Bourgeoisie. 








 

Monday, October 7, 2013

Comparing the Founding Fathers of Sociology







Comparative Charts and Graphs


This cartoon Graphic was made by Mooretoons for the CrankySociologist blog (http://mooretoons.com/2013/06/15/durkheim-vs-weber/)



This chart was made by your TA, Julia, and is specific to the concepts form our SOC1 course.


Sociological Perspective Theorist Level of Analysis
1. Symbolic Interactionism Max Weber Micro Cultural Structures --> shape social structures (Bottom Up)
2. Functionalism Durkheim Macro Social Structures (Institutions) shape cultural structures (beliefs) which influence life chances (Top Down)
3. Conflict Theory Marx Macro Social Structure (Mode of Production) CAUSE Cultural Structures
Bourdieu Micro and Macro Social Structure and Cultural Structures mutually constitutive – from the inside of the individual out AND the social structure down.